Donnie Broderick's Plumbing Handicap – Killarney

Killarney

18:50

Donnie Broderick's Plumbing Handicap

Date 2025-05-13

Distance 1m31y

Class

Going Good

Type Flat

Surface Turf

Age Band 4yo+

Prize €5,900

Winning Time 1m 44.26s (slow by 4.46s)

Result

Pos	Horse	SP	Btn
1st	Harry The Rogue (IRE) Sam Coen · Andrew Slattery	9/2	Won
2nd	Saxon Kingdom (IRE) Gavin Ryan · Thomas Dowling	9/2	2.75
3rd	Still She Blooms (GB) Jack Kearney · Chris Timmons	6/1	0.1
4th	Jurality (GB) Dylan Browne McMonagle · Paul W Flynn	10/1	.5
5th	Eagles Whistle (IRE) Chris Hayes · P J F Murphy	40/1	0.2
6th	Arthur Rose (IRE) Joseph Harnett · Mark Fahey	28/1	.75
7th	Deuteronomy (IRE) Nicola Burns · R P Burns	11/1	1
8th	Saith Seren (GB) Seamie Heffernan · Andrew Lee	10/1	.5
9th	Dazzling Spirit (IRE) Colin Keane · Cian Collins	7/2F	1.75
10th	Relevant Range (IRE) Darragh O'Sullivan · Gillian Scott	18/1	1
11th	Say You're Sorry (IRE) Killian Leonard · Eamonn O'Connell	33/1	.5
12th	Mogwli (IRE) Megan Telford-Kelly · W McCreery	16/1	1
13th	Second Fiddle (IRE) Wayne Lordan · C P Donoghue	22/1	1.5
14th	Haeret In Pectore (IRE) Shane Foley · A J Martin	33/1	4.5

Runners (15)

EW Terms: 3 places, ¼ odds (standard bookmaker terms — may vary)

#	Horse	Jockey / Trainer	Wt	Gear	Form	OR	RPR	TS	Last	Crs	Dst	Val	Scr	EW	Odds
12 (11)	Dazzling Spirit Bay J:Colin Keane T:Cian Collins	J:Colin Keane T:Cian Collins	125	—	7060-3	43	72	57	41d	—	—	-10	8.2	0.88/1	7/2 22%
Showed her best form for Tom Mullins in 2022, promising start for this stable last month
7 (10)	Harry The Rogue Bay J:Sam Coen(7) T:Andrew Slattery	J:Sam Coen(7) T:Andrew Slattery	136	—	635716	54	63	56	6d	—	—	-4	13.6	1.13/1	9/2 18%
Sixth behind Mogwli at Gowran, may struggle to turn the tables on fourth-placed Jurality
11 (3)	Saxon Kingdom Bay J:Gavin Ryan T:Thomas Dowling	J:Gavin Ryan T:Thomas Dowling	126	tp	566628	44	72	39	8d	—	—	-6	7.1	1.75/1	7/1 13%
Good second at Dundalk, ran creditably from out of the handicap at the Curragh last time
6 (1)	Still She Blooms Bay J:Jack Kearney(5) T:Chris Timmons	J:Jack Kearney(5) T:Chris Timmons	137	h	35-354	55	55	31	20d	—	—	-7	4.3	1.75/1	7/1 13%
Consistent form at Dundalk before a creditable fourth at Gowran, possibly best at 7f
8 (9)	Jurality Chestnut J:Dylan Browne McMonagle T:Paul W Flynn	J:Dylan Browne McMonagle T:Paul W Flynn	134	—	90-074	52	58	30	6d	—	—	-7	3.6	1.75/1	7/1 13%
Has come down in the ratings, worth considering following last week's fourth to Mogwli
14 (4)	Deuteronomy Bay J:Nicola Burns(7) T:R P Burns	J:Nicola Burns(7) T:R P Burns	122	—	08-935	40	68	50	20d	—	—	-6	2.4	2.50/1	10/1 9%
Has had plenty of chances, one of his better runs at Leopardstown on his penultimate start
5 (8)	Saith Seren Bay J:Seamie Heffernan T:Andrew Lee	J:Seamie Heffernan T:Andrew Lee	137	—	75620-	55	64	54	197d	—	—	0	6.5	3.50/1	14/1 7%
Career-best when second over C&D last October but that was on heavy ground
1 (15)	Mogwli Grey J:Megan Telford-Kelly(10) T:W McCreery	J:Megan Telford-Kelly(10) T:W McCreery	146	—	00-061	64	60	41	6d	—	—	-2	5.4	3.00/1	12/1 8%
Has gone up 7lb for Gowran win and may struggle to uphold form with fourth-placed Jurality
2 (7)	Relevant Range Bay J:Darragh O'Sullivan(7) T:Gillian Scott	J:Darragh O'Sullivan(7) T:Gillian Scott	142	p	000-49	60	63	16	18d	—	0W/1P 1 run	-2	4.1	4.00/1	16/1 6%
Ran well at Bellewstown on return, testing conditions probably against him at Limerick
15 (14)	Second Fiddle Bay J:Wayne Lordan T:C P Donoghue	J:Wayne Lordan T:C P Donoghue	122	t	0000-7	40	61	50	15d	—	—	-4	1.4	4.50/1	18/1 5%
Has failed to reach the first four in 12 starts, fair run behind Harry The Rogue on latest
3 (2)	Arthur Rose Brown J:Joseph Harnett(10) T:Mark Fahey	J:Joseph Harnett(10) T:Mark Fahey	139	b	9-5958	57	56	5	24d	—	—	-1	3	5.50/1	22/1 4%
1m4f stretched her stamina last time; previous 1m run at Cork was a lot better.
4 (5)	Haeret In Pectore Bay J:Shane Foley T:A J Martin	J:Shane Foley T:A J Martin	137	t	5214-0	55	37	17	8d	—	—	-1	2.2	6.25/1	25/1 4%
Won in Poland, can probably improve from Curragh run but appears held by Saxon Kingdom
9 (6)	Say You're Sorry Chestnut J:Killian Leonard T:Eamonn O'Connell	J:Killian Leonard T:Eamonn O'Connell	132	ht	4044-0	50	69	-	60d	—	—	-2	0.7	8.25/1	33/1 3%
Fourth in two 1m handicaps at Dundalk last summer, poor run over further on AW last time
13 (13)	Eagles Whistle Chestnut J:Chris Hayes T:P J F Murphy	J:Chris Hayes T:P J F Murphy	124	t	5-0800	42	70	-	6d	—	0W/0P 1 run	-2	0.8	10.00/1	40/1 2%
Weak form in handicaps, never in the hunt at Gowran last week, hard to make a case for her
NR (12)	Cu Chulainn Bay J:Rory Mulligan(7) T:Laura Hourigan	J:Rory Mulligan(7) T:Laura Hourigan	128	t	0008-0	46	67	40	18d	—	—	—	0	—	—
Both wins came on AW, losing run stretches back nearly three years, up against it

Horse	bet365	William Hill	Boyle Sports	Ladbrokes	Unibet
Dazzling Spirit	7/2	7/2	7/2	7/2	7/2
Harry The Rogue	9/2	9/2	9/2	9/2	7/2
Saxon Kingdom	6/1	13/2	13/2	6/1	7/1
Still She Blooms	7/1	7/1	7/1	13/2	13/2
Jurality	7/1	7/1	7/1	13/2	13/2
Deuteronomy	10/1	10/1	10/1	10/1	10/1
Saith Seren	14/1	14/1	14/1	14/1	14/1
Mogwli	12/1	12/1	12/1	11/1	10/1
Relevant Range	16/1	16/1	16/1	16/1	16/1
Second Fiddle	18/1	16/1	18/1	18/1	18/1
Arthur Rose	22/1	22/1	22/1	20/1	18/1
Haeret In Pectore	25/1	25/1	25/1	25/1	25/1
Say You're Sorry	33/1	33/1	33/1	33/1	33/1
Eagles Whistle	40/1	40/1	33/1	33/1	25/1
Cu Chulainn	-	-	-	-	-

Predictor

Scored on Official Rating (max 30), Recent Form (max 25), and Market Odds (max 20). Max score: 75.

1st

Harry The Rogue

13.6

OR: 1 Form: 7.6 Odds: 5

9/2

2nd

Dazzling Spirit

8.2

OR: 0 Form: 3 Odds: 5.2

7/2

3rd

Saxon Kingdom

7.1

OR: 0 Form: 3.5 Odds: 3.6

7/1

Saith Seren

6.5

OR: 1.3 Form: 3.5 Odds: 1.7

14/1

Mogwli

5.4

OR: 3.5 Form: 0 Odds: 1.9

12/1

Still She Blooms

4.3

OR: 1.3 Form: 0 Odds: 3.1

7/1

Relevant Range

4.1

OR: 2.5 Form: 0 Odds: 1.6

16/1

Jurality

3.6

OR: 0.5 Form: 0 Odds: 3.1

7/1

Arthur Rose

OR: 1.8 Form: 0 Odds: 1.2

22/1

Deuteronomy

2.4

OR: 0 Form: 0 Odds: 2.4

10/1

Haeret In Pectore

2.2

OR: 1.3 Form: 0 Odds: 1

25/1

Second Fiddle

1.4

OR: 0 Form: 0 Odds: 1.4

18/1

Eagles Whistle

0.8

OR: 0 Form: 0 Odds: 0.8

40/1

Say You're Sorry

0.7

OR: 0 Form: 0 Odds: 0.7

33/1

Cu Chulainn

OR: 0 Form: 0 Odds: 0

—

Ratings

Horse	OR	RPR	TS
Mogwli	64	60	41
Relevant Range	60	63	16
Arthur Rose	57	56	5
Still She Blooms	55	55	31
Saith Seren	55	64	54
Haeret In Pectore	55	37	17
Harry The Rogue	54	63	56
Jurality	52	58	30
Say You're Sorry	50	69	—
Cu Chulainn	46	67	40
Saxon Kingdom	44	72	39
Dazzling Spirit	43	72	57
Eagles Whistle	42	70	—
Deuteronomy	40	68	50
Second Fiddle	40	61	50

Last Run

Horse	Last Run	Status
Harry The Rogue	6d ago	Quick return
Jurality	6d ago	Quick return
Mogwli	6d ago	Quick return
Eagles Whistle	6d ago	Quick return
Saxon Kingdom	8d ago	Quick return
Haeret In Pectore	8d ago	Quick return
Second Fiddle	15d ago	Fit
Relevant Range	18d ago	Fit
Cu Chulainn	18d ago	Fit
Still She Blooms	20d ago	Fit
Deuteronomy	20d ago	Fit
Arthur Rose	24d ago	Fit
Dazzling Spirit	41d ago	Fit
Say You're Sorry	60d ago	Fresh
Saith Seren	197d ago	Long break